Black Hills Harvest? Show me the money!
Recently, local churches brought Greg Laurie’s Harvest event to Rapid City. Four contemporary Christian bands came with him to entertain the crowds. 19,000 people showed up to rock and roll and get with God.
According to local news reports, the event cost in the neighborhood of $400,000 to present. Local churches came up with about a third or $125,000 of that total. The Laurie home church, from what I can gather, put up the rest of the money, in the belief that the difference would be made up in collections from the audience and sales of goods like books, t-shirts, CDs and other ephemera sold by the promoters.
I heard from people at the show that buckets of money were collected. Buckets and buckets and buckets. This money went somewhere. I want to know, and you should want to know, where that money went. I hope it didn’t leave Rapid City and the surrounding area. But I think if the money were divvied up among the churches who raised the original money, they would be shouting it from the mountain top – Harney Peak maybe. However, I am guessing the money collected from the Black Hills audiences left on a bus for California never to be seen again.
Local news reports also indicated that although it cost so much money to present, Christian supporters believe the event was a success because 1,519 souls went forward to receive God and be saved. While I think this is a wonderful development for those souls, if it sticks, I personally have lived with God for as long as I can I can remember (although some parts of our relationship have sometimes been a bit rocky) and he is my rock and my strength, I can’t help but do the math. It’s in my nature.
$400,000 for 1,519 people to go up and receive God calculates to $263 per person. I entirely agree that it is well worth the money to save those souls if that is indeed what happened, but “I have me doubts.” Everybody can lay off cigs for a day, a week or a month, but in faith as in addiction, it’s the long haul that counts. I want records of past success. How many people came forward at last year’s Harvest? How many are still walking with God? Show me the money! Measure it in souls saved, fine, but let’s see your figures.
To put it in different terms, the United Way’s 2009-10 Rapid City area fundraising goal is $1.9M. $400K is 21% of that total goal. The United Way works for the betterment of local citizens year around, providing funding to get goods and services to the people who need them. If you donate to the United Way, you contribute to housing, feeding, and caring for local residents in a myriad of ways. Anyone who has taken a semester of human psychology, and paid attention, knows that until those basic physical safety and nutritional needs are addressed, people aren’t going to “get with God.”
Long story short, I think that putting on a show like Harvest is just that, a show. If the Christian people who supported this event monetarily would spend an equal amount of money in the local area, it would be money much better spent. Four hundred thousand dollars would fill the bellies of a lot of poor local children and we have plenty of them. It would heat a lot of local homes. It would pay for a lot of basic medical care. It would go a lot farther to fill the needs that need to be met before you can go about saving souls and it would be a much better proof that this is what Christians really care about.
